Should we eat meat only in winter and famine?

Posted on February 21, 2007 at 12:29 am

Doctrine & Covenants

Follow Gramps:

facebooktwittergoogle_plusredditpinterestlinkedinmail
Print Friendly

Question

Hi Gramps.

Lately I have been contemplating the Word of Wisdom. It seems I and others stop reading at verse 12 of Doctrine & Covenants 89. Because the verse after says, regarding eating flesh of animals, And it is pleasing unto me that they should NOT be used….only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine. In verse 15 it says, And these hath God made for the use of man ONLY in times of famine and excess of hunger. The Lord then steers us to Grains, fruits and vegetables in their season. My question is this – why are Mormon’s (gulp, including myself) such meat eaters? I don’t see any emphasis on “healthy eating” rather everyone thinks they’re hunky doory to be just not drinking alcohol, and smoking…. Please let us know your view on this. I’m ready to really cut back, if not cut out my meat consumption, because according to the Lord it would please Him, and I sure want to please him. Thank you kindly,

Melinda

 

Answer

Dear Melinda,

There is an interesting curiosity about verse 13 of Section 89 of the Doctrine and Covenants, which revelation is known as the Word of Wisdom. If you were to examine the early copies of that revelation you would find missing the comma after the word “used” in that verse. The present version of the sentence comprising verses 12 and 13 reads as follows:

Yea, flesh also of beasts and of the fowls of the air, I, the Lord, have ordained for the use of man with thanksgiving; nevertheless they are to be used sparingly, And it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used, only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine

The comma in question renders the meaning of the phrase as that it would be pleasing to the Lord if the flesh of beasts and fowls would not be eaten except during winter, cold or famine.

In the original versions, the last phrase was given as

And it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine.

The implication of this rendering is that it is pleasing to the Lord that the flesh of beasts and fowls should not be eaten only in times of winter, cold or famine, but it should be eaten in other times as well. That comma, in effect, reverses the meaning of the sentence. Where did the comma come from? It was added to the section by Elder James E. Talmage, of the Quorum of the Twelve, when he divided the Doctrine and Covenants into columns in 1920.

With the original rendering, the counsel with respect to eating the flesh of beasts and fowls is consistent with the rest of the section, and with the same topic addressed in other sections of the Doctrine and Covenants as well. Looking at verses 14 and 15—

All grain is ordained for the use of man and of beasts, to be the staff of life, not only for man but for the beasts of the field, and the fowls of heaven, and all wild animals that run or creep on the earth; And these hath God made for the use of man only in times of famine and excess of hunger.

This sentence clarifies what could be eaten in times of famine and excess hunger. We read here that grain is the staff of life, and that it is good for man and also for beasts of the field, and also for all wild animals. It is critical to the understanding of this passage that we determine the antecedent of the pronoun, these. What does these refer to?–the nominative noun that immediately precedes it–wild animals! And these [wild animals] hath God made for the use of man only in times of famine and excess of hunger. Now it makes good sense that wild animals may be used for food only when other sources are not available. This is consistent with Section 49 verse 21

And wo be unto man that sheddeth blood or that wasteth flesh and hath no need.

It is also consistent with D&C 49:18-19—

And whoso forbiddeth to abstain from meats, that man should not eat the same, is not ordained of God; For, behold, the beasts of the field and the fowls of the air, and that which cometh of the earth, is ordained for the use of man for food and for raiment, and that he might have in abundance.

Since he whoso forbiddeth to abstain from meats that man should not eat the same, is not ordained of God, it would be inconsistent to render Section 89 as directing that man should abstain from meats except in the stated emergency situations.

One additional point which is germain to this discussion is to understand that not only in the Doctrine and Covenants, but in the other scriptures as well, the beasts of the field are differentiated from wild animals. (See 2 Nephi 2:15; D&C 59:16; 88:14; 101:42; Moses 5:1; Ex 23:11; Deut.7:22, etc.) Thus, the beasts of the field are domesticated animals.

So, Medinda, you are enjoined to eat meat of domesticated animals sparingly, but at any season of the year. The Saints in those days were instructed to eat herbs and fruits in the season thereof, since because of lack of modern refrigeration or that transporting of fruits from other climates half way around the world in a few hours, they were only available in the season thereof.

 

Gramps

Summary
Article Name
Why, according to Doctrine and Covenants, Section 89, are we constrained to eat meat only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine. - Ask Gramps - Q and A about Mormon Doctrine
Author
Description
Lately I have been contemplating the Word of Wisdom. It seems I and others stop reading at verse 12 of Doctrine & Covenants 89. Because the verse after says, regarding eating flesh of animals, And it is pleasing unto me that they should NOT be used….only in times of winter, or of cold, or famine.

Follow Gramps:

Sending in questions to Ask Gramps

September 17, 2014 8:11 pm

At this time we are experiencing some technical difficulties when trying to submit a question to Ask Gramps.  Currently it doesn’t appear as if the question is going through (more)

Who are the 144,000 spoken of in Revelation?

September 17, 2014 8:26 am

Question Gramps, Who are the 144,000 spoken of in Revelation ? Thank you. Donna     Answer Dear Donna, Joseph Smith was asked the same question (along with (more)

Are there scriptural references that Christ was nailed to the cross?

September 16, 2014 8:10 am

 Question Gramps, I have been a member all my life and I had someone ask me a question and I was stumped. I have asked Institute teachers and (more)

Why not polyandry in the Celestial Kingdom?

September 15, 2014 7:49 am

Question Gramps, The subject basically says it all. It doesn’t make sense to me that Heavenly Father would treat his daughters and sons differently from one another. Why (more)

Where can I find Ezra Taft Benson’s talk about the last days?

September 9, 2014 10:50 am

Question Gramps, I keep hearing about a talk that Ezra Taft Benson gave in a devotional regarding events leading to the last days.  Have you heard of it (more)

Why wasn’t Priesthood authority restored first?

September 7, 2014 7:31 am

Question Gramps, If the Priesthood is the power of God given to men on earth, why was it not restored first? Wouldn’t this power and authority be  required (more)

What lesson did God want to teach Jonah in the story of the gourd and the worm?

September 5, 2014 7:49 am

Question Kia Ora Gramps.Could you please help to understand what lesson the Lord wanted to teach Jonah about the Gourd and the Worm? I’m having trouble understanding the (more)

Did Jesus receive temple ordinances?

September 3, 2014 8:28 am

Question Gramps, Did Jesus receive temple ordinances? I know he was baptized to fulfill all righteousness but he was sinless and didn’t need to be. So then did (more)

Can two people live together in a platonic relationship?

September 2, 2014 7:52 am

Question Gramps, I realize that we are to remain completely chaste before marriage, but what about cohabiting  with single persons of the opposite sex in a completely platonic (more)

How did Christ get anything done while on the earth?

September 1, 2014 6:00 am

Question Dear Gramps, I was just wondering how Christ, when He was on the earth, was able to get anything done, with so many things distracting Him.  For (more)

Why did God need Jesus to atone for our sins?

August 31, 2014 6:00 am

Question Gramps, With all of God’s knowledge and power, why did he need Jesus to atone and sacrifice for our sins? Sherlene   Answer Hello Sherlene, In teaching (more)

Why did we have the Civil War?

August 30, 2014 5:00 am

Question Gramps, Why did we have the American Civil War and what does it mean as said in DC 87? Will those people be saved due to fighting (more)